Scope Creep

Scope Creep

Scantron 

I decided to undertake a project in which my professional learning community transitioned from archaic Scantron™ testing to Data Director™. Data Director™ is a fantastic tool that allows educators to evaluate student responses, see problematic questions, compare data across teachers, across years, and across subject matter. Sounds amazing, right? The problem is, Data Director™ is not intuitive to use. Without proper training, this is quite an undertaking. The project that was planned to take 2 weeks, took months and was not successful at its first attempt. As the informal project manager (meaning the person with the bright idea to change over), I was wholly unprepared, and undertrained for what I was about to undertake. I saw another teacher using the tool, asked a few questions, and thought I could implement the changes in my department. Scope creep took over. Educators cannot print student score sheets to any printer. I was warned about this, and chose appropriately. A test must be shared with colleagues. This took a bit of extra time, but was accomplished. A score sheet must be created online before administering the test, and shared with colleagues. Easy, right? The template score sheet for multiple choice responses has answers A-D, my department needed A-E. It is possible to change the score sheet, but it took hours to figure out.

Finally, the test was administered, the score sheets, so meticulously printed, were filled in, and ready for scoring. The scoring takes place on a different machine located in our staff work room. The machine was turned on, and I logged in. The score sheets were placed on the scanner. And I learned the hard way, you do not score a Data Director™ test by going to the same Data Director™ site you use to upload tests, and score sheets. Once that was figured out, and new logins secured, I learned the hard way (noticing a theme?) parameters must be fairly exact for score sheets to read. Mine had not been fitted to a printable area upon printing, and were unusable. Apparently, this is a common problem. Once fitted to a printable area, sometimes, there are exceptions that must be viewed and cleared by the educator. Is it an amazing tool? Yes. But proper training and support are essential for success. Most departments gave up before seeing the amazing possibilities this tool and resource could provide. It was humorous how many colleagues saw me struggling, and laughed, or worse yet, said “we are supposed to use it, but have no idea how, after a lengthy training session”.

Research, research, research. I could have avoided these pitfalls if I had done my homework. I heard about, and assumed much with few, actual facts. With a knowledge of project management requirements and techniques, this would have been a very different experience. This year my whole professional learning community used this tool without a hitch. Experience is valuable, and when there is a lack of it, research is invaluable.

Everyone on my team was on board, as long as I figured it out in advance. If I had identified risks, assessed potential impacts of risks, developed plans for mitigating the impacts of the risks, monitored the status of a project’s risks throughout performance, and kept others informed (Portny, Mantel, Meredith, Shafer & Sutton, 2008) this could have been a very different experience, the first time through.

Reference

Portny, S., Mantel, S., Meredith, J., Shafer, S., & Sutton, M., (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

 

 

Advertisements

One thought on “Scope Creep

  1. Data Director sounds great if you could get it to work correctly. Am I understanding correctly that you are trying to find a different solution to the outdated scantron sheets? I was at the Ohio Educational Technology Conference this past week and found many different companies that offer this. GradeCam (http://www.gradecam.com/features/) is one company that offers a solution. GradeCam allows you to scan the test sheets with any camera (this can be an iPad or phone or anything else with a camera) and will make results charts/data information. You can share assessments with this program as well. Another company/website that offers a solution is Lightning Grader (https://www.lightninggrader.com/features/). This allows you to scan assessments already made into the computer and will have the test to be taken online. It allows to immediate grading and data retrieval. You can actually watch the results appear as your students are taking the test.

    Again, I saw these while at a conference and they sound intriguing. I am trying to get my district to allow me to pilot one of them for the rest of the year in order to see if it i something my department or building would like to take part in. I am by no means an expert on either of these products but they seem like something you and your colleagues might be interested in checking out especially since they appeared to be extremely user friendly (keyword is appeared, so again, not 100% sure on this).

    It is sometimes hard for educators to look at the risks when it comes to finding new technology. We see new, exciting and fun things to try in the classroom and run with it without thinking what can go wrong. Unfortunately, we normally find out pretty quickly exactly that–the downfall. It would be best for all of us to take a step back before attempting things in our classrooms until we have figured out the risks, but sometimes it is way too tempting to bring something new for our students or colleagues to enjoy.

    Good luck with it all–especially if your school is getting started on the testing coming everyone’s way!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s